Alesleo wrote:FlamingPup wrote:Birdo is a female.
Nope. Birdo is a male who thinks is a female. It was in the manual of Super Mario Bros 2, the game where he originally appeared. Later they sometimes referred to him as a female to protect the poor children from his "evil way of thinking"
He's not the only case of transgender changed to female for this reason. Poison from Final Fight comes to mind.
Well, I have three points to bring up here:
1) Super Mario Bros. 2 isn't considered canon because Mario wakes up at the end and the whole thing is apparently just a dream. Admittedly, that might also mean Birdo doesn't really exist either (within the Mario canon), but whether he/she/it does or not, the fact everything in that game was just a dream calls that into question.
2) Maybe it was just a typo or mistranslation in the manual. It wouldn't be the first time something like that has happened. Remember "Bimmy and Jimmy" in Double Dragon? or the "Conglaturations" at the end of Ghostbusters? Typos and errors were very common back in those days, particularly with many games being made in Japan and translators often doing a poor job at converting to English.
3) Regardless of the above, Birdo produces eggs, and that biologically implies that Birdo is a female. I mean, being pink and wearing a bow and believing you're a female is one thing, but when you literally produce eggs then... yeah.
BTW, wasn't there some controversy relatively recently about Samus really being transgendered or something? I didn't follow that so I don't know if there was anything to it, or if people just had their panties in a twist over nothing.